Why Comparing Caitlyn Clark to Angel Reese is Misleading

In the world of sports, we often draw comparisons between players to highlight their strengths or spark debate, but not all comparisons are fair or even remotely accurate. Picture a world where people are comparing Steph Curry, the greatest shooter in NBA history, to Andre Drummond, a player whose focus is defense and rebounding. These kinds of comparisons would be absurd, yet this is exactly what’s happening with WNBA stars Caitlyn Clark and Angel Reese.

Caitlyn Clark vs. Angel Reese: Performance on the Court

In the 2023 NCAA Championship, Angel Reese’s taunting of Caitlyn Clark brought both players into the media spotlight. However, even before their face-off, Caitlyn Clark was a recognized powerhouse, leading the league in points and assists. While Angel’s team did win that particular game, her stats pale in comparison to Caitlyn’s season performance. Since joining the WNBA, Caitlyn has continued to dominate, delivering impressive stats: 19 points, 6 rebounds, and 8 assists per game in her rookie season. Her most recent games saw her scoring upwards of 24 points with stellar three-point and free-throw percentages, pushing her towards MVP candidacy.

Angel, on the other hand, while impressive near the rim, lacks the diverse range that Caitlyn has. Her shooting chart shows limited performance outside of the paint, underscoring the gap between their skills. This stark contrast highlights how Caitlyn’s game is multi-dimensional while Angel’s strengths are mainly around close-range shooting.

Off-Court Differences: Commitment and Perception

Their differences go beyond statistics. Caitlyn Clark embodies dedication, working tirelessly to improve her game during the offseason despite already securing a record-breaking $28 million Nike deal. Meanwhile, Angel Reese’s public statements on how WNBA pay doesn’t meet her expenses, including her $8,000 rent, have sparked criticism. While it’s reasonable to acknowledge the financial realities of WNBA players, flaunting her earnings can feel out of touch for a league struggling to build its fan base and gain respect.

The Media’s Role and the Bird-Magic Comparison

Some fans and commentators have tried to equate the Clark-Reese rivalry to the legendary Magic Johnson and Larry Bird rivalry of the 1980s, which reshaped the NBA. But this comparison stretches the truth. Magic and Bird had complementary skill sets and were incredibly matched. In contrast, Caitlyn’s game is a blend of shooting range, court vision, and scoring versatility—qualities associated with NBA legends. Angel, though talented, doesn’t bring the same diversity or impact to her playstyle.

Since their 2023 NCAA face-off, Caitlyn has outperformed Angel in nearly every major statistical category and has even been instrumental in elevating her team to playoff contention, while Angel’s team has struggled. Caitlyn’s rookie season alone ranks as one of the best in WNBA history, likely paving the way for MVP titles if her momentum continues.

The Bigger Picture

Caitlyn Clark represents a turning point for the WNBA and women’s basketball, captivating fans worldwide and proving that women’s basketball can be as thrilling and skillful as any league. With her relentless dedication to perfecting her game, Caitlyn is setting a high bar for future players and bringing in fans who may have never watched the WNBA before.

In the end, comparing Caitlyn Clark to Angel Reese is as flawed as comparing Steph Curry to Andre Drummond. Both are talented players, but Caitlyn Clark’s skill set, achievements, and potential for elevating the WNBA are on a different level.